Adaptations
Movies, Arts & Lit | By Nicholas for The Top 13 on January 20, 2010
Ever since Cecil Hepworth adapted Lewis Carroll's Alice's Adventures in Wonderland for his 1903 film, aspiring screenwriters have looked toward literature for inspiration and stories with results all over the critical spectrum. Unfortunately, even after all that time, the simple question of what makes a "successful adaptation" has no definitive answer. Perhaps then, the best way to view adaptations is to consider them as films first, and then to pay attention to the amount of mileage the writers and directors got out of their source material. Accordingly, we present The Top 13 book-to-film adaptations.
|
|
1 |
No Country for Old Men2007 |
|
|
2 |
One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest1975 |
|
|
3 |
Adaptation2002 |
|
|
4 |
The Godfather1972 |
|
|
5 |
The Thin Man1934 |
|
|
6 |
The Silence of the Lambs1991 |
|
|
7 |
The Shining1980 |
|
|
8 |
A History of Violence2005 |
|
|
9 |
The Lord of the Rings Trilogy2001-2003 |
|
|
10 |
Apocalypse Now1979 |
|
|
11 |
To Kill a Mockingbird1962 |
|
|
12 |
Solaris1972 |
|
|
13 |
Where the Wild Things Are2009 |
PulpAffliction ★★
Eyes Wide Shut is so ridiculously underrated. Great film.
11:23 AM Jan 20, 2010
jasun ★
oof.
Shawshank Redemption.
oof.
A few more I would rank highly: Schindlers List, A Clockwork Orange and Midnight Cowboy.
10:45 AM Jan 20, 2010
stillathreat ★★
Not a bad list, but it's a broad topic. Might have been better to do this by decade or genre. Otherwise, you have the inevitable problem of missing some that other people definitely would have included, like A Clockwork Orange or Shawshank.
10:50 AM Jan 20, 2010
radiowxman ★
What, no "Battlefield Earth?" Seriously, you could do a top 13 just on Steven King novels turned movies.
11:30 AM Jan 20, 2010
fiveiron83321
no fight club?
I know it wasn't completely spot on with the book but it was still pretty good
11:57 AM Jan 20, 2010
zircona1 ★
Pretty good list. The Godfather was the first one I thought of when I saw the topic.
12:28 PM Jan 20, 2010
blix ★
I'm surprised Arcade Fire didn't make the list. Seriously though - soooooooo many options, definitely tough to pick a top 13. I disagree that you could do an entire list of Stephen King adaptations, most of the movies weren't nearly as good as the books. Shawshank and Shining are a couple of exceptions. (and I agree with Jasun, very surprised Shawshank didn't make the list)
12:39 PM Jan 20, 2010
abujabu ★
shawshank and where the wild things are mirror the usual adaptation in that the movie had to expand on a short story to make something more.
this list is essentially a referendum on movies that are better than their books. an argument that always ends with books winning, but not always rightfully so. Good call including adaptation, and the shining. I echo comments above regarding a clockwork orange but Im not sure the film surpasses the book in that instance it does live up to its high standards though.
In other news thetop13's coen brothes boner is showing and its massive! Hoping you can find a way to sneak them into the rest of your lists.
1:40 PM Jan 20, 2010
ajay ★★
Just wait until their True Grit remake comes out at the end of the year. All the lists will need updating.
5:55 PM Jan 20, 2010
tyrante
The only ones I have both read and seen are One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest and Where The Wild Things Are (I have seen Lord of the Rings but only read the first book).
I love Cuckoo's Nest, both the book and movie. I knew Kesey disliked the adaptation, but I didn't know it was because of the lack of emphasis on the Chief - that I find interesting. I wonder if the movie could have been just as successful trying to incorporate some of the surrealness of the narrative? Maybe not. Jack Nicholson is incredible in this.
I am SUCH a Dave Eggers fan (and now a McSweeney's devotee), but I really didn't like Where The Wild Things Are. :(
12:10 AM Jan 21, 2010
pookie
I had to echo some of the sentiments here and add that a lot of these 'books' were written like films which means there wasn't much leg work involved in turning them into movies. No Country for Old Men and The Road are a complete departure from McCarthy's earlier works in that they read like films. All the Pretty Horses was a much more literary work but was very difficult to turn into a film and that totally reads when you watch it. And I don't really think you can include something made from a graphic novel. If you're going to go there, you might as well add movies adapted from video games. Not much difference between a storyboard and a graphic novel so there's nothing to adapt really. Adaptation is an amazing adaptation because it is such a complete departure from the book. I'm kind of amazed that Orlean signed off on it. I know it's a super broad topic since, as has already been pointed out, almost everything you see in the theater started out as something else but I don't feel like a lot of these movies had much adapting to do.
9:15 PM Jan 21, 2010
ajay ★★
I'm unsure of what you mean when you say that those books read like films. Also, video games were probably considered, but what movie based on a video game do you think could make this list? The reason A History of Violence is on here is because the source material wasn't great, but it was turned into a great film. Also, there is a pretty major difference between a storyboard and a graphic novel, plus, the novel was adapted into a screenplay first, not directly into storyboards.
12:10 PM Jan 25, 2010
Please Join or Login to leave a comment








Facebook
Twitter
Digg
Stumbleupon
Delicious

ajay ★★
This must have been a tough list to put together considering about 95% of American films come from existing source material. Personally, not only do I think The Shining is the greatest adaptation, but also the greatest film of all-time. I would include two other Kubrick films - because let's face it, he's the best - which would have been A Clockwork Orange and Eyes Wide Shut. The latter was adapted from a terrible novella by Arthur Schnitzler and remains one of the worst things I've ever read, while the film remains Kubrick's most underrated film.
10:45 AM Jan 20, 2010